"Where the conversation between women goes next..."

Mother’s Day when you’re childless by circumstance, not choice.

It’s random events that set me off…

Walking past a schoolyard at pick-up time, noticing the little hands entwined in the safety of a mother’s grip. A friend sending me a text cancelling lunch as her five year old is home sick from childcare. My own mother wistfully telling me that she wishes she could put all my dreams in a box and give them to me. Although somewhat unrelated, they all represent something I don’t understand: a mother’s love.

They beg the question – what does it feel like? What is it like to feel your child’s hand in your palm, to nurse a sick baby, or to love someone so much that your dreams revolve around them. I can’t answer those questions. I don’t know what it feels like because I’ve never experienced motherhood.

This wasn’t the plan. I’d always intended to have children. Two to be exact. One at 25, and the second at 28. Over the years that 25 became 35 and the 28 turned into 38, but the plan was always in tact. But then, as is the case for so many of us, life stepped in the way of my plans.

At first I found myself in a succession of unsuccessful relationships, and then in the middle of my peak dating years (just when my selection of men was improving) I got struck down by an illness. For the next seven years, dating and motherhood became secondary to mere survival. They became things ‘other people did’ – they didn’t even warrant space in my life.

Author, Sharon Sztar. Image supplied.

Initially when I got better I thought I was over that phase; over motherhood. But its slowly been creeping its way back into my thoughts and life. Do we as women ever get over the desire to have children, even when we may have accepted its improbability? I see it in the eyes of talented and beautiful women I’ve questioned about whether they have a child, or wanted one if they didn’t. There is a look in their eyes, perhaps only recognisable by another childless woman. Their eyes may glaze over, a tear could form, or they may seem empty for a moment.

We have this womb, this space within us that was made to carry and bare a new human form. The process of conception and birth is truly miraculous. To be a part of that, to continue the cycle of life, is inherent to a woman’s body. How do we deal with not fulfilling our body’s legacy?

I appreciate some women have deliberately chosen not to have children and are OK with that. But I’m more regularly coming into contact with those whom the choice they feel they had little conscious input in to.

I am currently writing a book about my illness. I went through a stage where I had convinced myself that my book would be ‘my baby’. It would be my creation: my ‘replacement child’. I was stuck in a writers block for so long and didn’t know why. The content for the book only began to flow when I let go of this ‘substitution plan’ and realised that even though my book was going to be my creation, it wasn’t the same as giving birth to your own flesh and blood. I feel that I will never replace that void. It is irreplaceable. That doesn’t mean that I can’t fill my life up with other amazing experiences and deeply love another person, but I no longer believe that void in the womb is fillable.

Having a child is still in the realm of possibility for me. After shrinking to a weight of 37 kilograms during my illness, I lost my menstrual cycle, and along with everything else, my ovaries essentially shut down. With my return to health and vitality, I have begun to menstruate and ovulate once more.

My body is even forming child bearing hips! At 43 most would say I’m passed my peak. But after seeing a 48 year old friend of mine naturally conceive and give birth to her third child in five years, I believe a healthy and content body can surprise the best of us. I feel younger and more vibrant than I have in years.

Celine Dion fell pregnant with twins aged 42. Image via

I used to not want to be an older parent. Mostly because I thought it was cruel for the child. But now I see things differently. I have an innate wisdom and understanding about life that would’ve been lost to me in my 20s, and even my 30s. As one 40-something new parent recently remarked to me: “what you lack in physical stamina you make up for in an acquired confidence and attitude that only life experience can provide you with”.

The day I got my period back was one of the most joyous days of my life. I even returned some of my blood to the earth in gratitude and thanks, just like the women did many many moons ago in biblical times. I will never take this for granted again, nor will I ever complain about its existence.

Sonia Kruger became a mother at 48.

That old saying is right once again; unless you don’t have it, you don’t realise how much you actually miss it. Although my weight loss occurred due to my illness, and not due to an eating disorder or dieting, I worry when I see the number of women today preferring to be ‘ripped’, skinny and somewhat pre-pubescent, even if it comes at the expense of their monthly cycle and even worse, their fertility.

Re-entering the dating world proves interesting for me. When others in my peer group are making post-kid retirement plans, I’m looking for someone who is willing to potentially go the whole hog with me. Do I look for a younger man? Do I avoid men with kids?

One ex-boyfriend was scared off me when I said I wanted to have children, he already had two with two other women and wasn’t ready for another. And then there is the possibility that if you enter a relationship with a man with his own kids and you don’t fall pregnant, how will you cope with a daily reminder of what you don’t have? A fellow childless friend confided in me that she is going through this herself right now.

I have endless questions about what will happen if I don’t have children. Who will my family recipes go to? Who will take my treasured grandmothers jewellery? And what about the neatly packed boxes of Golden Books and Enid Blyton stories I’ve had stored in my parent’s garage for years?

Mariah Carey had her twins when she was 40. Image via

The one thing that frightens me above all is what will happen if and when my own parents pass on before me. It is common to hear recent orphans say that when their parents died, they turned their attention to the next generation. Isn’t that just the cycle of life? But what happens when that version of life isn’t your version?

I remember thinking this when I was sitting anxiously by the phone waiting for my parents to call from hospital when one of my grandparents was dying. I knew when they got home we’d all be able to give each other a big hug. Who will I hug? There is something about this idea of there being someone else on this planet that either you came from or they came from you.

The potential of this not being so for me, sometimes flips me. These questions although not at the forefront of my mind on a day to day basis, do haunt me, especially when faced with one of those random events, or even something like Mother’s Day.

Once I attended a personal development workshop when I was the only member in the group that wasn’t a parent. In a particular exercise I was told by the group leader that “it would all make sense when I became a mum”. Apparently, love would take on a whole new dimension. What if that doesn’t happen?

What I have accepted is that fate has my path in mind. I won’t push the baby agenda, yet I won’t let it go either. If it happens, it happens. If it doesn’t, I guess a whole bunch of random events will continue to stir me up, and I’ll always wonder what a mother’s love feels like.

Sharon Sztar is a writer, blogger and presenter based in Byron Bay. With a focus on health and wellness, her insights are based on direct experience in the industry as well as her own personal illness and recovery journey. With a Bachelor of Economics behind her, she also has over fifteen years experience working across marketing and communications in the corporate arena.
Related:
Here are the comments
  • StephanieJCW

    God I love this so so so much. I could have written every word. I am 34 and unlikely to ever have children purely because my dating life is and always has been a complete and utter disaster. No reason, just pure bad luck. It’s hard when people aggressive question you as to why “you’re settled with kids” as if they cannot understand why you can’t just snap your fingers and make it happen.

    And then yes there is the problem of being surrounded by children, how dating becomes harder as the men you meet have children and how do you deal with that. I have even had the same thoughts about my womb “going to waste” if I never have a child.

    As another “childless by circumstance” person, thank you.

  • Shalmee

    I agree with Ev if you want it that badly, do it. I spent years playing the martyr and not having a baby because my life wasn’t perfect enough and it would be selfish and unfair to the child. At 39 I realised that hey life’s not like that and it’s ok to be a little selfish sometimes! Fortunately after one round of IVF I conceived my amazing daughter. Grab what you want don’t wait, good luck xx

  • Carla

    You can be grateful while still craving something. She says she is happy and healthy, and feels better than she has in years. It’s not really fair to roll your eyes at someone else’s dreams and desires. I’ve known a few people who have that burning desire to be a mother, and if they couldn’t I know the pain of ‘what they can’t have’ actually would be a very real, acute pain that would be hard to cope with.

    Sharon, don’t give up hope. I’m sure you’ve considered all the options available to you (IVF, adoption, dating sites with your desire for children listed) and are going with what’s right for you. Here’s hoping it happens for you one day!

  • Tamaresque

    I was in the same boat. I decided to work with children instead. That cured me! I loved it, by the way, and it hit me hard when I had to give it up for health reasons. It doesn’t pay well monetarily (I gave up being a career public servant!) but the rewards are more than money is worth.

  • Leanne

    Thank you Sharon. Your account is exactly how I feel although circumstances slightly different. No one telling you to get over it and get on with being happy with your life helps. I am happy with my life – I have wonderful friends and family, and many experiences and achievements that make me proud and happy to be alive. But they don’t fill the hole. I fear that hole will always be there and it’s healthy to acknowledge that. I sincerely hope you do experience motherhood.

  • Steph

    I’m sure Teenagers will love having grandparent aged parents. The very real possibility of losing their parents before they are 30. The rough and tumble play with tweens I’m sure will be out, backs and hips won’t take it. Heaven forbid you have a child with special needs.The list goes on.

    Falling ill through your “prime” years is a tough break but it’s also not why most women miss their chance. They choose work or adventure. Maybe their standards high – All good reasons to miss the boat but they made that choice now they need to live with it.

    • Cazzie

      Wow tough Steph. I had my boys at aged 37 and 38. Not because of work, but because I was after a partner who also wanted children. I finally found someone when I was 30. Spent some time trying , miscarrying, ect. I can keep up with my boys no sweat and I am 45. My boys wont loose us when they are 30, I plan to be around for sometime. As for hips and backs, lve had arthritis since I was 16, no probs there. I dont think you give us older parents much credit.

    • StephanieJCW

      I hate this kind of stereotype. Many of us didn’t choose adventure, or career not do we have spectacularly high standards. We just haven’t been able to make a relationship last. My “choice” was single motherhood or no children. I choose the latter as I believe a family environment is necessary to raise children.

      As for children with older parents, I doubt they care. My father loves his father who was in his 40s when my father was born. My parents had me as teens but I don’t recall being especially grateful they were young. I just care about having a loving parent.

  • CVW

    I had my first child at 38 and my 3rd at 42; Naturally. Anything’s possible.

  • Rhonda

    Thank you Sharon for sharing your feelings and your journey with us, beautifully written, reading your story brought tears to my eyes, you are a very strong and determined women it shows by what you have overcame and by sharing your journey Iam sure will inspire and help many who have the same experiences Thank you and I will be looking forward to reading your book

  • ev meyer

    Sharon…here is my advice…direct and to the point because there is no time to waste. Go to the sperm bank, get a sperm donor and have a baby…the man can come later. My best friend did it at 44 and it has totally enhanced her life in so many ways. Stop contemplating ladies….just do it,just do it….time waits for noone

    • StephanieJCW

      I have no interest in a child without a family. If I just wanted a baby I would have already done that.

  • wene_housen

    Hmmm, I think this author needs to actually start being grateful for what she has instead of pining for what she doesn’t. Life often doesn’t work out the way you plan. I lost 2 parents at age 5 and have never known my real father, I am 40 and don’t have kids as I’ve never been in the financial position to be able to do it. Mother’s Day bothers me because I don’t have a real mother to give a card and present to. But the thing is, I’m happy. I’m happy with the life I have, with the friends I have, with the experiences I have had in life. I’m afraid the whole “And then there is the possibility that if you enter a relationship with a man with his own kids and you don’t fall pregnant, how will you cope with a daily reminder of what you don’t have? ” eye roll worthy.

    I understand I have the benefit (If it can be seen that way) of having parents taken from me very young, which taught me that life is precious, every day we should be thankful just for the life we have and the breath in our bodies, the freedom we have to create the life we want to live. If you want kids so badly you’ll adopt or date someone with kids, and if that person doesn’t want more kids – love the children that they have. Why hold out and get even older again holding out for this childhood dream?

    The author of this article is seeking some picture perfect fantasy and at her age she can’t afford that. I’m 40 so I more than understand how fast the years travel by, and at our age, if you want something you need to act now. Date someone with kids, or adopt, or do IVF and be a single mother, and if you can’t have your perfect picture, learn to love the lesser picture you’ve managed to create instead. Everyone of us has unfulfilled dreams, but you have to make peace with it.

    If I held out for my childhood dreams I’d be a mess, I was going to be an astronaut, and a super famous pop star. I was going to travel the world. Get married. Things change, stop holding out for some picture perfect life you (and we all) dreamt of as a child. You have options, but it’s you who is standing in your own way by holding out for this knight in shining armor who will join you and raise a biological child with you. I’m not saying it can’t or won’t happen, but at some point if it hasn’t happened and you still desperately want children, you’re going to have to find other means and lower your expectations in order to fill that void.

  • Kellie Leonard

    I understand how she feels. I feel like women are digging a knife into me when they ask if I have children. It makes me feel like I’m being judged, and deep down I just want to burst into tears, being reminded of what I’m missing out on.

  • Eccles

    I appreciate the topic and Sharon’s individual viewpoint. Please proofread articles, the grammatical errors let the standard of the site down.

  • Vivien Resofsky

    Thank you Sharon Sztar for this honest and personal account of what if feels like not to be a mother, when you would dearly love to be one. This is an inspiring article. You are left with the feeling that this strong woman will be just fine, as she leaves it to fate and gets on with life and all its pleasures and challenges.