"Where the conversation between women goes next..."

‘I find the idea of ‘taking my husband’s name’ repelling.’

I’m getting married in three months. I am not changing my name. In fact, I find the idea of “taking my husband’s name” repelling.

I understand the best thing about feminism is choice. And it’s great that women can choose. But I just don’t understand why you would choose to lose your name?

I’m divorced. If I’d taken my first husband’s name I’d be Shelly Cockerill. Kind of sounds like a porn name or sea bird. No deal.

But now I’m getting married again and my fiance has a great last name. Robinson. I could be Mrs Robinson.

Here’s to you, Mrs Robinson.

Mrs Robinson, you’re trying to seduce me aren’t you?

But giving away my name feels like giving away my identity.

I’ve worked hard in my career. I’m known by my name. To me it would be like Coke changing their name to Penelope just because they love someone. It just doesn’t make sense.

A former boss of mine presented an argument for journalists to keep their maiden name throughout their careers. She was an industrial relations reporter in the UK. She got married. Moved jobs. Moved cities. But because she kept her maiden name, a whistle-blower in an asbestos case tracked her down. He said she was the only one he trusted and if he hadn’t been able to find her he would have taken the secrets to the grave. His story changed laws and lives.

Celebrities who changed their names (post continues after gallery).

Outside of journalism, what if you are made a named partner in a law firm and then got married and changed your name? Would the firm have to pulp their letterhead and business cards?

I threw the question open to friends.

“Men don’t change their names. Women are already disadvantaged at work and get paid less. Why add confusion about your name as well? Men don’t,” says a friend.

“I changed mine because: a) I liked his better, b) my dad’s family didn’t bother to stay in touch with us when he left and my husband’s family have welcomed me with open arms over the ten years we’ve been together, so they feel much more like my family. I don’t feel like I lost my identity.”

“I have a name I use at work and a name I use at home,” says a friend.

Shelly and her fiance, Darren.

For some, it’s not a work issue.

“No way would I change my name, because I’m not my husband’s property. This is historically how this came about. Namely for the consolidation and protection of assets,” harrumphs one friend.

“I decided when I was five that I wasn’t changing my name and I’ve never wavered. I just don’t get it. I like my name. He can take mine if he wants to. I don’t see why it should automatically be the woman to sacrifice her identity,” says another.
“I added my husband’s onto the end of mine, because I wanted to, because I like it and because I feel very much a part of his family. My sister changed hers — doesn’t meant she’s lost ‘her identity’, that’s ridiculous,” says one friend.
Identity chat put the cat among the pigeons. If you legally change the way you are identified, how is that not losing your identity?
“I guess it depends on where you find your identity. Because I view ‘a name’ and ‘someone’s identity’ to be two different things in a lot of cases,” she says.
That argument is becoming too “the artist formerly known as prince” for my liking.
Hello? Is it me you’re looking for?
A common reason women say they want to change their names is so that they have the same names as their kids. But this doesn’t make sense to me either. Surely these days, kids can cope with different last names. It’s not like they don’t know who their mum is. They have different first names and they seem to be okay. Give them credit.

“I didn’t change my last name for ten years but then all my son’s friends kept calling me Mrs Porter and then my son started calling our family the Porters, then added “except mum”. I changed it immediately,” says a friend.

“I changed my name. For lots of reasons. Including because it’s my kids’ name. Guess the fact is, I had the choice, and that was the choice I made,” says another.

What about you? Did you change your name? Did you have any regrets?

Like this? Why not try …

Can marriage be happy without sex? This woman says yes.

After years of marriage, a love letter to my husband.

The secret to a happy marriage.

Here are the comments
  • Jessenia

    I’m not married but when I do marry to my fiancee I’m taking his last name… Cuz I feel more part of his family than my own and simply I love how my name sounds with his last name which is Milano

  • Hugo B

    As with sexual orientation. Who cares, only you and your partner. No need to make an issue of it. If your partner does not like your attitude. I’m sure he can walk away and take it as a warning of things to come…

  • Phoe

    Yes for all of this! I never want to change my name, and for a few reasons.
    1. If I took my partner’s name, I would become Phoebe Fry. I don’t like the way it sounds. Too much ffff.
    2. My last name has famous Scottish history attached to it and I cannot bear to part with it.
    3. Because I want to use my right to choose my name and my identity.

  • ELMIRA N

    I would not ever want to take a man’s last name, I’m my own individual person and it’s like becoming not so individual anymore, for me personally. To me it’s like the principle of sleeping with a guy in order to have his heart, (which obviously never works out). love people who take one another’s last names, everyone to their own.

  • Kerrie

    Ive been with my boyfriend for 2yrs and the conversation of marriage does come up occassionally. My partner is fully aware that im not taking his name. If i took his last name i would be “kerrie coyne” and i just think it sounds silly. Thats the main reason, but there is also a little feminist voice in my head thats also saying “why should i??? (take his name) Ive worked my ass off for my dream job since i was 17 years old, and ive only just “arrived” (im now 26) i love my job, im the ‘breadwinner’ in our house, i have status at my organisation and also in the community. Thats also my identity. the thought of having kids in the next couple of years makes me very excited, but also very aprehensive. Giving up all that i have worked so hard for to go on maternity leave for a year, and then return “part time” makes me sad… and thats just for 1 kid! Add another 18mths per child after that.
    I feel like i already have identity sacrifices to make, just let me keep this one thing – my surname.

  • Maree

    “Repelling” is, on the one hand, taking a ‘read between the lines’ swipe at women who HAVE taken their husband’s surname (whilst possibly offending the writer’s future husband at the same time?). Is it really that bad that you find it “repelling” – which, by definition, means “be repulsive or distasteful to”. Wow.

    If someone said that “I find it unnecessary”, rather than “repulsive”, as being the reason not to change one’s surname after marriage, I’d agree. This article is either a little too self indulgent, or edited for ‘click bait’?

    If a woman wants to keep her name, then she should keep it – more power to her. But, please, don’t get on a rooftop or some tall horse and tell the world how repugnant you find the thought of taking someone else’s surname in marriage. Same sex couples do it – so what are your thoughts on that?

    Great step forward for the ‘sisterhood’, right? Make your choices, but take a cheap swipe at other women who don’t make the same decisions. Why must women always bring down other women in the process of fighting for equality? Men don’t do it.

    Amal Clooney might disagree with your sentiments.

    • StephanieJCW

      I think you’re being over sensitive. She is allowed to find things repugnant and voice her opinion on it. We don’t have to like the choices people make, as long as we respect their right to make that choice.

      And I doubt her husband would be offended. Millions of men would have the same reaction to taking their wives name (hence why so few do it.) doesn’t seem to bother the women they marry.

  • Doringrosie

    I took my husband’s name when I married. Before that, I had my father’s name. I love my father, but I no longer lived with my mother and father, I live with my husband. Changing to his name, helped me to make the transition from living in my parents’ household, to living in my own household. I do not make unilateral decisions in my new, married household, my FAMILY (me and my husband) make decisions TOGETHER. I don’t run home to my family when things get rough – I stay and work it out.

    My husband wanted to know if I wanted to hyphenate my surname and I said no, I want to shorten it, not lengthen it! (My maiden name was LONG and my married surname is only 4 letters). There is never enough space to write down my e-mail address.

    Some women keep their maiden name in a professional capacity (all her diplomas are in her maiden name, she has made her career in her old name, etc.), but takes her husband’s name legally to separate business from personal.

    That said, it’s a very personal choice and my reasons might not work for someone else. These days it’s possible to choose; there was a time when it was taken for granted a woman takes her husband’s name.

    • StephanieJCW

      It wasn’t your father’s name it was your name. Of course if you change your name or not is your business. But can we stop referring to women’s name as “their fathers” when we never say the same about men. Interestingly you refer to your husband’s name as his name not your “father-in-law’s” name.

    • StephanieJCW

      As for your reasons, surely they apply just as much to your husband, equally a reason for him to change his name? And equally you can have a unified household where husband and wife make joint decisions have got two names.

      I don’t see why women struggle to rationalise their choice. Just say you like the tradition so wish to stick to it!