"Where the conversation between women goes next..."

‘My mum is an ‘anti-mother’ – and doesn’t care who knows.’

I try to see it as a blessing that Mother’s Day is the one day a year where having a parent who doesn’t want to be a parent really pays off. I don’t have to send my mother any Mother’s Day cards or flowers; I don’t have to express my love or gratitude for her giving me life in any of those standard ways.

I’m completely off the hook – even saying “Happy Mother’s Day” to her would upset her.

She doesn’t believe in celebrating Mother’s Day, just like the way she doesn’t believe in family. I’ve gotten used to having a mother who’s remarkably different from the kind of mum most people have — you know, the loving, nurturing, and mothering kind of mothers.

My mother is the anti-mother.

Christine

She considers Mother’s Day a manufactured holiday; therefore, to acknowledge it in any way would be pandering to the greeting card and flower industries. I don’t understand her logic, but I’ve never been good at translating my mother’s ways.

I think it would be nice to have a day of appreciation. Although I’m not a mother, a wife, or even a secretary, I would never despise anyone because they wanted to show their appreciation for me.

If I sent my mother a Mother’s Day card, she would rip it up and use the blank portions as note cards.

I wish I could believe that my mother knows she hasn’t been a good mother and doesn’t deserve any parenting accolades. But I don’t think she’s concerned with her parenting skills; she’s far too narcissistic to care about how other people are feeling, especially people related to her.

This is a woman who didn’t even go to her son’s funeral or her nephew’s wedding. It wasn’t that she didn’t go to protest the event, just that she didn’t feel compelled to go out of a sense of love or family.

In some ways it’s understandable that she doesn’t believe in a lot of holidays. It isn’t out of some religious belief; it’s because she doesn’t believe in anything that stresses family togetherness.

If I sent my mother a Mother’s Day card, she would rip it up

For most people, giving birth to a child creates a bond that never dies but my mother seems to be missing this gene. Both my brother and my father have passed away, and you’d think that would make my mother more interested in the remaining members of her family, but it doesn’t.

She’s perfectly happy having a neighbor take her to her doctor appointments, or spending Thanksgiving by herself with her cats and dog.

There are parents who live vicariously through their children, but that’s not how my mother rolls. She’s shown little interest in what is going on in my life. When I had swimming lessons at age 7, she sat under a tree reading. I’d shout at her, “Look at me, Mum! Look at me!” but she wouldn’t take a second to stop reading her book and acknowledge me.

My mother has always been very disconnected, rather than connected to her family members. She’s never been the excessively affectionate — a distracted kiss on the cheek at bedtimes was about as lovey-dovey as she got.

Once, as a child, I became so angry with her that I swore I would never kiss or hug her again.

I realised I had given her a gift when she didn’t pursue any kind of affection reconciliation. I kept my vow for years and was the one who finally broke my own pact.

It seemed odd not to touch my own mother, and odder still for her not to want me to. As evidence of this disconnect, there are a number of pictures of me with my mother where she looks as she’s in a completely different room.

While she wasn’t gifted in the ways of mothering, she did take good care of me when I was sick. She’d feed me soup, read me Wizard of Oz books, and put cold compresses on my forehead. She was a good nurse and when she had her first face lift, I returned the favor.

I picked her up in a cab (I didn’t have my driver’s license yet), made her tomato soup, and got her prescription for pain medication filled. I felt that I had paid my debt to her.

Despite the fact that my mother considers herself to be an agnostic, she prays that I will lose my house and be forced to live with her.

God comes in handy when you want what is best for yourself — not what is best for your daughter. It isn’t that she enjoys my company so much, just that she would like to cash-in on all the care-giving she gave me when I was sick. It infuriates her that I might not be willing to sacrifice my life for a woman who never put me first.

Mother’s Day is difficult for me with everyone posting on social media about how much they love their mothers and how much their mothers loved them. I can’t be sure that my mother has even a small place in her heart for me, her only living child.

I’m not convinced that she isn’t happier when we are completely separated, no ties between us, for my mother not only doesn’t believe in family … she doesn’t believe in me.

This post originally appeared on yourtango.com

More content from YourTango:

10 warning signs your relationship is making you depressed.

Treating post-coital depression.

5 new, alternative ways to treat depression without meds.

 

Here are the comments
  • Kate

    My mother also was never one to give hugs or kisses or do anything much other than criticise whenever I failed to achieve what she knew I could. However, based on the fact that my main memories of the first 15 years of my life were of my mother doing everything possible to keep her four children in one piece despite my father coming home from the pub as an angry drunk roughly 2 or 3 times a week on average and beating the living daylights out of her, with the occasional marital rape thrown in just to round that rosy picture out; I overlooked the fact that she wasn’t a person who displayed any love or affection and instead focused on the fact that she made sure I got through my childhood with a roof over my head, food on the table, and as complete an education as I was willing to pursue.

    Years later in my late 20s I found out about her childhood history – her mother and father had, early on in their marriage, a major disagreement which lead to an ongoing home environment for my mother and her siblings which was a very cold, silent battleground between the two adults, and in which my mother had to fight to get her own self through her education since she received no emotional or financial support from her parents to do so. It explained much to me of the way in which she herself had learned to interact with others on an emotional level, and the forces which formed her adult personality.

    So, my mother and I, we rarely hug. We do so much more now than when I was a child – these days it’s maybe once a year, possibly twice at the most. Despite this, she is THE most important, respected, and beloved person in my life. She, above all others, will leave me bereft and despondent when the day comes when she is gone.

    I’m just saying … maybe you should try to stop criticising your mother for what you perceive as her failures towards you, and instead focus on who you should be as a person towards her instead. You don’t know everything about her. There are likely reasons why she is the way she is. Are people’s value to you only worth as much affection as they have overtly displayed? After all, despite your assertion that she “doesn’t believe in [you]”, I doubt very much that your mother would desire your return to live under her roof unless she wanted and valued your company, whether she’s able to express this openly or not.

    This is a woman who, in your own words, fed you soup, read the Wizard of Oz to you, and put cold compresses on your forehead, yet you accuse her of not putting you first.

    Cut her some slack.

  • Carolyn Lee

    poor woman has suffered somewhere along the way and obviously its still a secret, and she did put you first your lucky you got to go to the pool,got fed and nursed when sick ,at her age she was probably forced into a marriage she didn’t want ,that happened for all sorts of reasons ,maybe one of the children is a product of rape,and she had to accept something that happened through force,if her attention was soley on herself she would have left years ago women have done it as far back as civilisation goes, woman had been made to shut up and do as told and never speak of particular issues,maybe you should seek the help of a counsellor for yourself,you do sound very bitter ,with a dash of hate , maybe they can help you understand how people behave when affected by deep rooted trauma/lifestyle ,consider yourself lucky there are thousands of kids out there that don’t get fed,dont get nursed as for the pool lol never ever and i hope you find compassion for someone who is still responsible for you actually being alive after all back then she could have dropped you on your head and just say you fell , wouldnt have spent a day in jail hmm i wonder who she put first? but yes seek help so you don’t end up the same way as her ,cycle must be broken especially if you have a girl